May 27th, 2009

Field Report: Vidalia Onion Pie

While I was careening through boggy farm fields in Southwest Missouri (in the intrepid John Deere Gator, no less!) this past weekend, my daughter and her friend Jenn were on their own road trip exploring some of the rural mountain communities of north Georgia. They called me on Sunday morning, excited to report about an event they chanced upon in the twee town Dahlonega: a Pie Tasting.

Now, this was not your ordinary country pie tasting, but Dahlonega is no ordinary country place. Set in the foothills of the Appalachian mountains, it was the site of our first gold rush. (That’s where “There’s gold in them thar hills!” originated..and you can still pan for it, for a price.) Today its rustic setting is the hub of several wineries, and boasts a creative spirit: with performing and visual arts, festivals, and recreational activities.

And, if the Pie Tasting is any indication, there is also some very good food.

Designed as a fundraiser for their local Literacy Council, this Pie Tasting featured 75 varieties of both sweet and savory concoctions. With names to set you salivating: Strawberry-Rhubarb with Brown Sugar Crumble. Rustic Spinach-Feta-Red Pepper Phyllo Tart. Upside-Down Key Lime Pie. Roasted Herbed Vegetables in Puff Pastry. Mile High Chocolate Meringue Pie.

The girls set their cell on speakerphone so that we could have a conference on the tasting.

“They charged $10.00, which entitled you to 5 different slices,” Madeleine said. “I figured, there’s no way we could possibly eat that. But we were wrong.”

“Soooooo very wrong,” said Jenn.

The girls’ favorite pie, hands-down, was the Vidalia Onion with a Cornbread crust.

“We had to have a second slice. It was Crazy Good.”

I’ve made onion tarts, traditional French model, with a basic pate-brisee crust, never with cornmeal. I had never considered that as a possibility. With Vidalias now readily available, this decidedly southern twist was worth replicating.

“The crust was really more like cornbread,” Madeleine explained. “And the filling had kernels of corn in it.”

“And, it was a little custardy,” Jenn continued.

“Quiche-like?” I asked.

“Yes, but, packed with vidalias!” Madeleine said.

“So sweet!” Jenn said.

“Mmmmm. I think I’ve got the picture,” I said.

Vidalia Onion Pie with Cornbread Crust

The Crust
½ cup Cornmeal ( I used white cornmeal, but either work)
½ cup All Purpose Flour
1 teaspoon Baking Powder
½ teaspoon Salt
1 egg
2 Tablespoons Butter
4 Tablespoons Ice-Cold Water

1 9 inch pie pan, coated with baking spray

Sift dry ingredients together and place in food processor fitted with pastry cutter blade. Add egg, butter, and pulse until mixed. Add water, a tablespoon at a time. This will form a sticky mass of dough.
Press into the prepared pie pan. If the dough is too sticky, add a little cornmeal.

Vidalia Onions are naturally sweet, but lightly caramelizing makes them outstanding.


The Filling

3 medium Vidalia Onions, sliced
1 Tablespoon Butter
½ cup kernel Sweet Corn (can be fresh or frozen)
1 cup shredded White Cheddar Cheese
2 eggs
1 cup Half-and-Half
½ teaspoon Salt
¼ teaspoon Black Pepper
4 sprigs Fresh Thyme

Heat a large skillet, then melt butter. Add onions and toss until lightly coated. On medium heat, saute the onions for about 15 minutes, stirring occasionally, until caramelized. Remove from heat.

In a bowl, beat the eggs and half-and-half together well–no traces of yolk.

Layer the bottom the pie with about half of the shredded cheese. Sprinkle with corn kernels, then add the onions. Pour the egg custard mixture over this. Top with remaining cheddar, the leaves from the sprigs of thyme, and a few grindings of black pepper.

Bake in a preheated 375 degree oven for 40 minutes—top will feel set and be nicely browned.

Serves 4-6

Posted in Egg/Cheese Dishes, Recipes, Vegetables

11 Responses to “Field Report: Vidalia Onion Pie”
  1. Shanley Says:

    This looks so good! I am definitely going to make this sometime.

  2. Judy DePalma Says:

    This looks fantastic, I can’t wait to try it! Big hello to Madeleine from Judy. Thanks, Nance.

  3. Bev Leiser Says:

    Cannot wait to try this pie….would bacon be a good addition in place of the corn?

  4. goodfoodmatters Says:

    Bev–yes, absolutely! I was just speaking with a friend and mentioned that bacon would be delicious in this pie–still very southern.
    (of course, there is a prevailing food theory that bacon is delicious with everything—some truth to that, I suppose!)
    Roasted poblano or hatch chili pepper would be quite good too, for a more southwest take.

  5. Amanda Says:

    Sounds amazing! I am sending this recipe along to my yankee boyfriend who just purchased $1.69/lb vidalias in NYC at my request. He schlepped an armfull home from the store so this should make him happy!

  6. Patsy Vaughan Says:

    There is hardly anything you can do to or with a Vidalia onion that I wouldn’t like, but this sounds particularly yummy!

    I second the bacon, but why instead of corn? Bacon and corn play well together – at least at my house.

  7. Madeleine Says:

    The other very special thing about this pie– cornbread crust. Boy howdy, does that make for a tasty pie! I’m going to attempt to make such a pie very soon. In the meantime, Jenn and I have photos of us at the tasting that we’ll try to share.

  8. Jennifer T Says:

    This looks a lot like what we ate in Dahlonega, but the onions look more caramelized in your version, Nance, so I think that will make the end result even sweeter and more flavorful. Why, the deep golden color of those onions makes me shout, “there’s gold in that thar pie!” Thanks for recreating this special treat!

  9. rhonda Says:

    yes, the bacon and roasted poblano sound like wonderful additions.

    but, i do make one exception to your comment:
    (of course, there is a prevailing food theory that bacon is delicious with everything—some truth to that, I suppose!)
    ……….bacon’s not so good in cocktails, as i’ve recently discovered. :-p

  10. goodfoodmatters Says:

    Rhonda—True enough! We all did not Love the Bacon Old Fashioned, but there are those who apparently do…

  11. Good Food Matters » Blog Archive » Quinoa Crust for a Savory Southwest Veggie Tart Says:

    […] had success with cornmeal crust in the past, why not […]



Comment on This Post: